Children Should Not Witness Euthanasia, Judge Rules


dog paw in handShould A Child Witness Euthanasia of a Pet?

After a two-week trial, a New York woman was convicted of child endangerment charges for allowing a 10-year-old to witness dogs being euthanized. While the judge ruled that euthanasia of the dogs in question was merited, he ruled that starting the euthanasia process in front of a 10-year-old was "egregious," according to the Associated Press.

Mona Kanciper, who operates a farm in Manorville, on eastern Long Island about 50 miles from New York City, faces up to a year in jail on the endangerment charge when she's sentenced Dec. 13. Kanciper apparently euthanized the dog by injecting it with a solution commonly used to put down animals. According to reports, the dogs were an aged Saint Bernard, a Great Dane mix that had bitten a delivery man and a husky mix that had killed a cat. He said she euthanized the dogs by injecting them with a solution called SomnaSol, commonly used to put down animals.

The girls who witnessed the unfortunate event were students who took horseback lessons at the farm, which bills itself as a horse rescue facility.

What do you think about this issue?

Unmerited euthanasia is an entirely different issue. However, if euthansia is merited (e.g., a pet with failing health that cannot be saved, an elder pet who has lost the use of their limbs), should a child witness such a thing...perhaps as a way to say goodbye to their pet? What do you think?


Follow fascinating, funny, tragic or otherwise compelling and timely stories about animals, as chosen by our editors and writers, including Daily Treat blogger, Janet McCulley.

Go Behind the Scenes with Animal Planet Staffers

play sport fishing






stay connected

our sites